Skip navigation menu
  • Indiana Citizen

    Nonprofit seeks more competitive elections in Indiana by looking beyond Rep & Dem candidates
  • Indiana Capital Chronicle

    Group backing independent candidates wants Indiana to end straight-ticket voting
  • Fox59

    Independent Indiana releases new study, advocates electoral changes
  • PRESS RELEASE
    New Independent Indiana study recommends three reforms to return competitive elections to the state
  • Indianapolis Business Journal

    Nathan Gotsch: Elected officials critical of their parties in private
  • Indianapolis business Journal

    Guest Column: The dirty little secret about Indiana elections

  • PRESS RELEASE
    Independent Indiana Responds to Governor Braun’s Call for Special Session on Redistricting
  • Crossroads politics - WTHR

    Crossroads Politics covers our recent polling data
  • WTHR

    On Voter Discontent and Low Approval Ratings for Republicans
  • kendall & Casey Show – WIBC

    Nathan Gotsch from Independent Indiana joins with some recent polling results on Governor Braun
  • PRESS RELEASE
    ‘You’re not alone’: Indiana poll finds dissatisfaction with leaders, parties, state direction
  • WTHR

    Poll shows majority of Hoosiers are not for redistricting
  • Indiana Capital chronicle

    New poll reports majority of Hoosiers oppose redistricting
  • PRESS RELEASE
    Hoosier voters favor reforms to straight ticket voting and ballot access
  • Memo: North star opinion research

    Election Reform Findings
  • Sheila Kennedy

    An Intriguing New Non-Party
  • Newsletter

    Newsletter for September 30th: Our First Month In Review
  • WIBC

    Independents Make Gains in Indiana Elections
  • All indiana politics - WISHTV

    New organization aims to boost independent candidates
  • Transcript and Video

    Panel Discussion: Independent Leadership in Indiana
  • PRESS RELEASE

    Independent Indiana adds national political organizer ahead of Indianapolis panel

  • IndianaPOLIS business journal

    ‘Leadership recession’ also fertile ground for change

  • Transcript and video

    Panel Discussion: Lessons for Indiana from the National Independent Movement
  • kendall & Casey Show – WIBC

    Independent Indiana pushes for fairer elections
  • WOWO

    Breaking the Mold: Mayor Richard Strick’s Independent Success in Huntington
  • WRTV

    On The Success of Independents In Indiana
  • WRTV

    Independent Indiana pushes to put more nonpartisan candidates on ballots
  • Indiana week in REview - Wfyi

    Indiana Week in Review panel discusses Independent Indiana
  • WFYI

    Independent Indiana launches ad campaign to promote appeal of nonpartisan leaders
  • WFFT

    Promoting independent candidates: Independent Indiana launches TV ads
  • PRESS RELEASE
    Independent Indiana launches statewide TV ads highlighting independent leadership
  • WTHR

    'Independent Indiana' aims to help break the two-party mold
  • INDIANAPOLIS BUSINESS JOURNAL

    Guest Column: Surprising Indiana election data suggests a reason for hope

  • WOWO

    New Initiative To Help Independent Candidates

  • INDY STAR

    Can independent candidates make our elections more competitive? This new group is making the push

  • Indiana Capital Chronicle

    Indiana initiative supporting independent candidates launches

  • PRESS RELEASE

    Initiative focused on returning competitive elections to Indiana announces statewide launch

  • PRESS RELEASE

    Independent Indiana announces Nathan Gotsch as executive director

  • Axios indianapolis

    Ending straight-ticket voting was once a Republican priority. Independents are pushing for it now.
Dec
15
2025

Fox59

Independent Indiana releases new study, advocates electoral changes

INDIANAPOLIS — An initiative aimed at promoting independent candidates in Indiana released a new study on Monday, one that the organization hopes to help Indiana out of a period of what they call “sustained political stagnation.”

Within Independent Indiana’s recent study on competitive elections, the group calls for the elimination of straight-ticket voting, along with changes to the signature requirement for independent candidates in the state of Indiana.

This comes after Independent Indiana released a series of polls earlier this year, including one centered around the state’s redistricting effort as well as another surrounding whether or not Indiana is on the right track politically.

Within the study, the group aimed to answer questions surrounding the competitive nature of elections in the state, many of which the group claims is decided before the general election through partisan primaries, party caucuses or districts designed to be held by one party.

“The result is a negative cycle: fewer competitive races, weaker accountability, policy incentives skewed toward the most ideological voters and declining public engagement,” the executive summary of the study read.

The study aims to look at what could be learned from the independent candidates who have won in Indiana, and what reforms and investments are likely to restore competition and accountability in elections.

“Indiana’s democracy will not be renewed through a single reform or a single election cycle,” the study’s executive summary read. “But this study’s findings point to a clear opportunity: Hoosiers want fairer elections, more choices and leaders who are accountable to voters rather than party machinery.”

The recommendations that the organization offered in the study include:

  • Repeal straight-ticket voting

  • Returning the signature requirement threshold for independent candidates to 0.5%, the figure it was at before the state’s 1980 legislative session

  • Build durable campaign infrastructure for independent candidates, including training, toolkits and membership networks.

“We launched this study because we wanted to understand what’s really happening across our state—how big the problem is, what’s driving it, and where we might find hope,” said Nathan Gotsch, executive director of Independent Indiana. “We gathered data, interviewed experts, and listened to people from every corner of Indiana and every part of the political spectrum. We also looked closely at a growing number of independent candidates who are making an impact in their communities.”

“Indiana is a place with a proud independent streak and a long tradition of innovation,” Gotsch continued. “…This study began as an effort to understand whether independents could compete at higher levels, but it quickly evolved into something much bigger. We ended up with a comprehensive picture of how our political system actually works—and an in-depth examination of possible remedies to return competitive general elections within four years.”

Ultimately, the group stated that Hoosier voters deserve better than the status quo, something that they believe the study is “clear in.”

“The reforms recommended in this study represent real change and opportunity,” said Jay Chaudhary, a member of the board of the Center for Independent and Effective Government, the parent organization of Independent Indiana.“The reforms recommended in this study represent real change and opportunity.”

For a look at the full study, look at the document below. For more information about Independent Indiana, click here.